Sleeping Duck vs Forty Winks: online mattress or in-store?
The short answer
Sleeping Duck sells online and also publishes a Melbourne showroom. Forty Winks sells in store and online, and states it has over 110 stores across Australia. Both are in our catalogue. Neither column is a winner. Read the trial rules on their pages before you treat a night-count as a refund.
Claire searches 145 products across 14 Australian retailers.
Claire is free. DOME may earn a referral commission when you click through to a retailer. This is fit preference, not medical advice.
How they compare
| Sleeping Duck | Forty Winks | |
|---|---|---|
| In our catalogue | Yes | Yes |
| Where you can try it | Online, plus a Melbourne showroom at 8 Carlton Street, Prahran VIC 3181. Sleeping Duck says you can test the starting feels Medium and Firm there. Showroom | In store and online. Forty Winks states it has over 110 stores across Australia, for advice and in-person trials. Forty Winks |
| Trial they publish | 100 Night Guarantee. Within that period Sleeping Duck says you can arrange a full return and refund of the purchase price, on up to two mattresses per household. Mach II includes free firmness adjustments, and they ask you to try each feel for 21 nights. FAQ | 90 Night Comfort Guarantee on selected ranges. Forty Winks says it is an exchange only, not a refund. Sleep on it for at least 30 nights, then contact the store of purchase between day 30 and day 90. You need proof of purchase and a Forty Winks approved waterproof protector bought on the same invoice and used from the first night. One exchange, same size, eligible range only. 90 Night Comfort Guarantee |
| Firmness words | Soft, Medium, Firm and Extra Firm. FAQ | Ultra Plush, Plush, Medium, Firm and Ultra Firm. Forty Winks also says firmness labels vary between brands. Mattresses |
| Warranty we could read | 10 year limited mattress warranty on mattresses Sleeping Duck manufactures, for purchases via sleepingduck.com. Warranty | A mattress warranty length was not on the 90 Night Comfort Guarantee page, so none is stated in this column. |
| Catalogue listing | View at Sleeping Duck | View at Forty Winks |
Frequently asked questions
I liked a mattress at Forty Winks. Should I still try Sleeping Duck because of the trial?
This page does not tell you to switch. The trials are different, so read both before you treat a night count as a refund. Sleeping Duck publishes a 100 Night Guarantee: contact them within that period for a full return and refund of the purchase price, on up to two mattresses per household. Mach II also includes free firmness adjustments, and they ask you to try each feel for 21 nights. Forty Winks publishes a 90 Night Comfort Guarantee on selected ranges only. It is an exchange, not a refund, after at least 30 nights and before day 90. You need proof of purchase and a Forty Winks approved waterproof protector bought on the same invoice and used from the first night.
Is lying on a mattress in the shop for a few minutes anything like sleeping on it at home?
Neither brand treats a few minutes in the shop as the whole trial. Forty Winks says your body needs time to adjust and asks you to sleep on the mattress for at least 30 nights before a comfort exchange. Sleeping Duck asks you to try each firmness for 21 nights during the 100 Night Guarantee. A shop lie-down and those home trials are different checks.
If I buy Sleeping Duck without trying it and don't love it, how does the return work?
Sleeping Duck's FAQ says to contact them and they will arrange a full return and refund of the purchase price at no cost within the 100 Night Guarantee. They limit that return to two mattresses per household.
Can I change the firmness during the trial instead of sending the whole mattress back?
On Sleeping Duck's Mach II, they publish free firmness adjustments inside the 100 Night Guarantee, across Soft, Medium, Firm and Extra Firm, and they ask you to try each feel for 21 nights. That is an adjustment, not only a full return. Forty Winks' 90 Night Comfort Guarantee is an exchange for another eligible mattress, not a firmness change on the same mattress.
Can I lie on a Sleeping Duck before I buy?
Yes. Sleeping Duck publishes a Melbourne showroom at 8 Carlton Street, Prahran VIC 3181, and says you can test the starting feels Medium and Firm there. You can also order online.
Ask Claire to Find Your Match
Claire searches 145 products across 14 Australian retailers. Tell her your sleep position, firmness preference, and budget.
Start Free Consultation →